108th CONGRESS
2d Session
H. R. 4399
To establish certain conditions on the Secretary of Veterans Affairs
implementing any recommendation of the CARES Commission that would have the
effect of eliminating or severely reducing any medical service provided to
veterans throughout the United States at Department of Veterans Affairs medical
facilities.
IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
May 19, 2004
Mrs. KELLY introduced the following bill; which was referred to the Committee
on Veterans' Affairs
A BILL
To establish certain conditions on the Secretary of Veterans Affairs
implementing any recommendation of the CARES Commission that would have the
effect of eliminating or severely reducing any medical service provided to
veterans throughout the United States at Department of Veterans Affairs medical
facilities.
Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United
States of America in Congress assembled,
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.
This Act may be cited as the `Securing Access to Vital Entitlements for U.S.
Veterans Act' or the `SAVE US VETS Act'.
SEC. 2. FINDINGS.
Congress makes the following findings:
(1) Veterans have sacrificed tremendously on behalf of their Nation and
deserve the best quality health care and benefits that were promised to
them by their country.
(2) The Veterans Equitable Resource Allocation (VERA) formula, established
by the Department of Veterans Affairs pursuant to section 429 of the fiscal
year 1997 VA/HUD appropriations Act (Public Law 104-204; 110 Stat. 2929),
has proved to be an ineffective means of allocating veterans medical care
dollars fairly across the 22 national service regions, known as Veterans
Integrated Service Networks (VISNs), of the Department of Veterans Affairs.
(3) A study by the General Accounting Office released in February 2002 found
weaknesses in the Department's implementation of VERA, such as the omission
of about 20 percent of VA's workload in formulating each network's allocation
and VERA's lack of accounting for the cost of differences among networks
resulting from variation in their patients' health care needs as well as
it could, which `compromise VERA's ability to allocate comparable resources
for comparable workloads'.
(4) The same General Accounting Office study found that failure to implement
the General Accounting Office's recommendations has resulted in the misallocation
of $200,000,000 annually by the Department and $920,000,000 that would otherwise
have been awarded to veterans health care facilities in the northeast and
was instead granted to the south and southwest.
(5) In May of 2004, the Secretary of Veterans Affairs announced the Secretary's
decision with respect to implementation of recommendations of the commission
established by the Secretary on December 22, 2003, known as the Department
of Veterans Affairs Capital Asset Realignment for Enhanced Services Commission
(or the CARES Commission).
(6) That May 2004 decision of the Secretary of Veterans Affairs would diminish
veterans' health care options by breaking promises and pushing deserving
veterans away from the veterans health facilities designed and built to
provide care and treatment to the veterans who have suffered on the battlefield.
(7) The CARES Commission failed to include mental health as part of its
criteria during its completion of its February 2004 report to the Secretary
of Veterans Affairs.
(8) The May 2004 decision of the Secretary of Veterans Affairs to move acute
and long-term psychiatry beds, without proper and sufficient data on mental
health of the affected veterans, is premature and ill-conceived.
(9) The consolidation of services, closing of hospitals, and removal of
services, which the Secretary of Veterans Affairs claims will `enhance patient
care', will only worsen and decrease services available to the Nation's
veterans.
SEC. 3. LIMITATION ON THE SECRETARY OF VETERANS AFFAIRS IMPLEMENTING CERTAIN
RECOMMENDATIONS OF THE CARES COMMISSION.
(a) LIMITATION- The Secretary of Veterans Affairs may not implement any recommendation
of the CARES Commission described in subsection (b) until the health care
funding allocation system for the Veterans Health Administration in effect
on the date of the enactment of this Act, known as VERA (Veterans Equitable
Resource Allocation), is replaced with a new, more equitable formula for the
allocation of funds appropriated to the Department of Veterans Affairs.
(b) COVERED RECOMMENDATIONS- This section applies to any recommendation of
the CARES Commission that is contained in the report of that commission dated
February 2004 and that would have the effect of eliminating or severely reducing
a medical service provided to veterans throughout the United States at Department
of Veterans Affairs medical facilities.
(c) CARES COMMISSION- In this section, the term `CARES Commission' means the
commission established by the Secretary on December 22, 2003, known as the
Department of Veterans Affairs Capital Asset Realignment for Enhanced Services
Commission.
END