108th CONGRESS
2d Session
S. 2733
To promote freedom, fairness, and economic opportunity by establishing
a National Enterprise Zone system to promote prosperity in economically depressed
areas.
IN THE SENATE OF THE UNITED STATES
July 22, 2004
Mr. BROWNBACK introduced the following bill; which was read twice and referred
to the Committee on Finance
A BILL
To promote freedom, fairness, and economic opportunity by establishing
a National Enterprise Zone system to promote prosperity in economically depressed
areas.
Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United
States of America in Congress assembled,
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE; TABLE OF CONTENTS.
(a) SHORT TITLE- This Act may be cited as the `National Enterprise Zone Act
of 2004'.
(b) TABLE OF CONTENTS- The table of contents of this Act is as follows:
Sec. 1. Short title; table of contents.
Sec. 3. National Enterprise Zones.
SEC. 2. FINDINGS.
(1) a higher level of private sector economic activity is necessary to alleviate
poverty and unemployment in economically depressed regions of the United
States;
(2) removing tax disincentives to reside or do business in economically
depressed areas is an effective means of promoting economic growth, development,
employment, a higher standard of living, and a higher qualify of life in
economically depressed areas;
(3) lower marginal tax rates on work, savings, and investment in economically
depressed regions will promote employment, business activity, and development
in economically depressed areas; and
(4) improved taxation of business investment in plants, equipment, and inventories
in economically depressed areas will encourage business to operate in those
areas.
SEC. 3. NATIONAL ENTERPRISE ZONES.
(a) IN GENERAL- Chapter 1 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 is amended
by inserting after subchapter Y the following new subchapter:
`Subchapter Z--National Enterprise Zones
`Sec. 1400M. National Enterprise Zone designation procedure.
`Sec. 1400N. National Enterprise Zone eligibility criteria.
`Sec. 1400O. Effect of National Enterprise Zone designation on individuals,
estates, and trusts.
`Sec. 1400P. National Enterprise Zone individual taxable income.
`Sec. 1400Q. Effect of National Enterprise Zone designation on corporations.
`Sec. 1400R. National Enterprise Zone corporate taxable income.
`Sec. 1400S. Conduct of an active trade or business within a National Enterprise
Zone by corporations, partnerships, and sole proprietors.
`Sec. 1400T. Definitions and special rules.
`SEC. 1400M. NATIONAL ENTERPRISE ZONE DESIGNATION PROCEDURE.
`(a) NOMINATED ZONE- The governor of a State or United States Territory or
the Mayor of the District of Columbia may nominate one or more zones for consideration
by the Secretary. This nomination shall take the form of a written application
submitted in the manner and form prescribed by the Secretary. Such application
shall contain all of the information necessary to determine whether a nominated
zone meets the National Enterprise Zone eligibility criteria.
`(b) APPLICATION DEADLINE- The nomination application shall be submitted after
January 1 and before February 28 of the year prior to the proposed effective
date of the zone.
`(c) DEFICIENCIES DEADLINE- The Secretary shall inform the nominator of any
procedural noncompliance by the nominator with the application procedures
or of any needed information that may be missing from the application by issuing
a deficiency notice no later than April 30 of the year that the application
was submitted.
`(d) CURING DEADLINE- The nominator shall cure any deficiencies set forth
in the Secretary's deficiency notice by May 31 of the year in which the deficiency
notice was issued. Failure to timely cure such deficiencies shall constitute
the withdraw of the nomination application.
`(e) DESIGNATION DEADLINE- The Secretary shall make a determination with respect
to any nomination application no later than September 30 of the year in which
the application was received. If the Secretary finds that a nominated zone
meets the National Enterprise Zone eligibility criteria set forth in section
1400N, then the Secretary shall designate such zone as a National Enterprise
Zone no later than September 30 of the year that the application was submitted.
If the Secretary finds that a nominated zone does not meet the National Enterprise
Zone eligibility criteria set forth in section 1400N or that the application
does not contain sufficient information to determine whether a nominated zone
meets the National Enterprise Zone eligibility criteria set forth in section
1400N, then the Secretary shall decline to designate such zone as a National
Enterprise Zone and shall, not later than October 31 of the year the application
was submitted, provide to the nominator a rejection notice setting forth with
particularly the reasons why the application was rejected.
`(f) NO PREJUDICE WITH RESPECT TO PREVIOUSLY NOMINATED ZONES- Whether a zone
or a substantially similar zone has been nominated in previous years shall
not be regarded by the Secretary as relevant when evaluating whether to designate
a nominated zone as a National Enterprise Zone.
`(g) APPLICATION CONTENTS- The application submitted by the nominator shall
contain--
`(1) an enumeration of all of the census tracts to be included in the zone;
`(2) census data for each tract with respect to median household income
in that tract;
`(3) census data for each tract with respect to the poverty rate in that
tract;
`(4) the laws of the State or Territory that conforms to the requirements
of section 1400N; and
`(5) such other information as the Secretary may require.
`(h) EFFECTIVE DATE OF ZONE DESIGNATION- The effective date of the designation
of any zone as a National Enterprise Zone pursuant to this section shall be
January 1 of the year following its designation. A designation shall continue
indefinitely, subject to annual eligibility reviews under subsection (i).
`(i) ANNUAL ELIGIBILITY REVIEW- Between January 1 and April 30 of the sixth
year of a National Enterprise Zone's initial effective date and each year
thereafter, the Secretary shall undertake a review of each National Enterprise
Zone designation whereby the Secretary shall determine whether the zone continues
to meet the National Enterprise Zone Eligibility Criteria established by section
1400N. If this review determines that a National Enterprise Zone no longer
meets the National Enterprise Zone Eligibility Criteria established by section
1400N, then the Secretary shall revoke the designation effective the end of
the calendar year. No later than June 30 after such determination, the Secretary
shall issue a notice to the nominator and to all taxpayers making National
Enterprise Zone elections with respect to such zone in the taxpayer's previous
taxable year that the designation will be revoked at the end of the calendar
year for such National Enterprise Zone. The Secretary shall publish the annual
eligibility review results for all National Enterprise Zones no later than
June 30 of each year.
`SEC. 1400N. NATIONAL ENTERPRISE ZONE ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA.
`(a) NATIONAL ENTERPRISE ZONE ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA- A National Enterprise
Zone must--
`(1) be composed of contiguous census tracts (none of which may be part
of an existing National Enterprise Zone);
`(2) have greater than 10,000 residents;
`(3) have a poverty rate 2 times the national poverty rate;
`(4) have a median household income less than 60 percent of the national
median household income;
`(5) have an unemployment rate 2.5 times the national average unemployment
rate; and
`(6) be located entirely within a State or Territory that the Secretary
certifies has enacted conforming laws within the meaning of subsection (e).
`(b) SPECIAL RULE FOR SMALL INCORPORATED CITIES OR SMALL COUNTIES- Paragraph
(2) of subsection (a) shall not apply to a zone if the zone comprises an entire
incorporated city or an entire county provided that such incorporated city
or county existed on the date of enactment of this subchapter.
`(c) NO OVERLAP WITH EXISTING ZONES OF DIFFERENT TYPE- No part of a National
Enterprise Zone may also be a part of--
`(1) a zone designated under subchapter U as an Empowerment Zone, an Enterprise
Community, or a Rural Development Investment Area; or
`(2) a zone designated as a District of Columbia Enterprise Zone under subchapter
W.
The nominator of a proposed National Enterprise Zone may indicate in his application
that some or all of an existing zone described in the previous sentence shall
lose its designation as an Empowerment Zone, Enterprise Community, Rural Development
Investment Area, or District of Columbia Enterprise Zone upon its designation
as all or part of a National Enterprise Zone. Such existing zone shall lose
such designation upon its designation as all or part of a National Enterprise
Zone in a manner prescribed by the Secretary.
`(d) DATA- No later than November 30 of each year, the Secretary shall designate
which data as of which date shall be used by nominators to perform the calculations
required in subsection (a) in applications made the following year.
`(e) CONFORMING LAWS- A State or Territory shall be deemed to have enacted
conforming laws if--
`(1) it is in substantial compliance with the No Child Left Behind Act of
2001; and
`(2) its tax laws provide for either--
`(A)(i) a substantially similar income tax base with respect to business
income arising from the conduct of an active trade or business within
a National Enterprise Zone as that provided for Federal income tax purposes;
and
`(ii) tax rates no higher than that imposed on businesses without a National
Enterprise Zone; or
`(B) the imposition of no income tax with respect to business income arising
from the conduct of an active trade or business within a National Enterprise
Zone.
`SEC. 1400O. EFFECT OF NATIONAL ENTERPRISE ZONE DESIGNATION ON INDIVIDUALS,
ESTATES, AND TRUSTS.
`(a) INDIVIDUAL ALTERNATIVE NATIONAL ENTERPRISE ZONE TAX- If for any taxable
year, any individual taxpayer who is resident in a National Enterprise Zone
for the entire taxable year has any National Enterprise Zone taxable income,
then, in lieu of any tax imposed by section 1 or section 55, such individual
taxpayer may elect, in a form prescribed by the Secretary, to pay a tax for
such taxable year which shall consist of the sum of--
`(1) a tax computed on the taxable income of the individual taxpayer for
such taxable year reduced by the amount of National Enterprise Zone tentative
taxable income of such individual taxpayer for such taxable year (if greater
than zero), at the rates and in the manner as if this subsection had not
been enacted; plus
`(2) a tax of 17 percent of the National Enterprise Zone taxable income
for the taxable year.
`(b) INDIVIDUAL TAXPAYER- For purposes of this section, an individual taxpayer
shall include an--
`(2) married individual filing a joint return;
`(5) married individual filing a separate return;
`(c) CERTAIN INDIVIDUALS, ESTATES AND TRUSTS-
`(1) JOINT FILERS- In the case of married individuals filing a joint return,
both individuals must have been residents in a National Enterprise Zone
for their entire taxable year in order to be eligible under this section.
`(2) INDIVIDUALS RESIDENT IN MULTIPLE ZONES- Individuals who are residents
of 2 or more National Enterprise Zones during their taxable year but are
residents of a National Enterprise Zone for their entire taxable year shall
be eligible under this section.
`(3) ESTATES AND CERTAIN TRUSTS- The estate of an individual and testamentary
trusts of an individual shall be eligible under this section if the decedent
was a resident of a National Enterprise Zone for at least two complete taxable
years prior to the individual's death.
`SEC. 1400P. NATIONAL ENTERPRISE ZONE INDIVIDUAL TAXABLE INCOME.
`(a) NATIONAL ENTERPRISE ZONE INDIVIDUAL TENTATIVE TAXABLE INCOME- National
Enterprise Zone tentative individual taxable income shall be equal to taxable
income (as defined by section 63 and computed without regard to section 179(e))
plus the additions set forth in subsection (b) less the deductions set forth
in subsection (c).
`(b) ADDITIONS TO TAXABLE INCOME TO DETERMINE NATIONAL ENTERPRISE INDIVIDUAL
TENTATIVE TAXABLE INCOME- The following amounts shall be added to taxable
income for purposes of determining National Enterprise Zone individual tentative
taxable income--
`(1) any amount excluded by section 103;
`(2) any amount excluded by section 105;
`(3) any amount excluded by section 106; and
`(4) any amount excluded by section 125.
`(c) DEDUCTIONS FROM TAXABLE INCOME TO DETERMINE NATIONAL ENTERPRISE INDIVIDUAL
TENTATIVE TAXABLE INCOME- The following amounts shall be deducted from taxable
income for purposes of determining National Enterprise Zone individual tentative
taxable income--
`(1) the taxpayer's distributive share of any partnership item (within the
meaning of section 702) that is not attributable to the conduct of an active
trade or business within a National Enterprise Zone;
`(2) the taxpayer's pro rata share of any S corporation item (within the
meaning of section 1366) that is not attributable to the conduct of an active
trade or business within a National Enterprise Zone; and
`(3) income derived from business that does not constitute the conduct of
an active trade or business within a National Enterprise Zone.
`(d) NATIONAL ENTERPRISE ZONE INDIVIDUAL TAXABLE INCOME- National Enterprise
Zone individual taxable income for any taxable year shall be National Enterprise
Zone tentative individual taxable income for such taxable year less--
`(1) net savings (as defined in subsection (e)) for such taxable year;
`(2) capital gains for such taxable year subject to tax under section 1(h),
but only if the property the disposition of which gave rise to the gain
was acquired by the taxpayer at a time the taxpayer was a resident of a
National Enterprise Zone;
`(3) expenditures made to acquire inventory property during such taxable
year;
`(4) the amount, if any, the taxpayer elects to deduct pursuant to 179(e)
for such taxable year that exceeds the limitations in section 179(b);
`(5) deductions reduced pursuant to section 68; and
`(6) amounts by which the exemption was reduced pursuant to section 151(d)(3).
`(1) GENERAL RULE- Net savings means deposits or contributions to nonqualified
financial accounts less withdraws or distributions from nonqualified financial
accounts held.
`(2) NONQUALIFIED FINANCIAL ACCOUNTS- A nonqualified financial account means
an account maintained with a bank (other than a checking account), a regulated
investment company, an investment bank, or a brokerage firm that is not
a qualified trust or account within the meaning of subchapter D.
`(f) TAX UPON LEAVING ZONE- The cumulative sum of net savings deducted pursuant
to subsection (d)(1) (if greater than zero) shall be includible in gross income
and taxed at a 17 percent rate upon a person becoming a non-resident of a
National Enterprise Zone.
`SEC. 1400Q. EFFECT OF NATIONAL ENTERPRISE ZONE DESIGNATION ON CORPORATIONS.
`(a) CORPORATE ALTERNATIVE NATIONAL ENTERPRISE ZONE TAX- If for any taxable
year, any corporation (other than an S corporation) has any National Enterprise
Zone taxable income, then, in lieu of any tax imposed by section 11 or section
55, such corporation may elect, in a form prescribed by the Secretary, to
pay a tax which shall consist of the sum of--
`(1) a tax computed on the taxable income of such corporation for the taxable
year reduced by the amount of National Enterprise Zone tentative corporate
taxable income for such taxable year (if greater than zero), at the rates
and in the manner as if this subsection had not been enacted; plus
`(2) a tax of 17 percent of the National Enterprise Zone taxable income
for such taxable year.
`SEC. 1400R. NATIONAL ENTERPRISE ZONE CORPORATE TAXABLE INCOME.
`(a) IN GENERAL- National Enterprise Zone Corporate tentative taxable income
for any taxable year shall be taxable income (computed without regard to section
179(e)) arising from the conduct of an active trade or business within one
or more National Enterprise Zones during such taxable year.
`(b) ADJUSTMENTS- National Enterprise Zone Corporate taxable income for any
taxable year shall be equal to National Enterprise Zone Corporate tentative
taxable income for such taxable year less--
`(1) expenditures made to acquire inventory property held in a National
Enterprise Zone in such taxable year; and
`(2) the amount, if any, the taxpayer elects to deduct pursuant to 179(e)
for such taxable year that exceeds the limitations under section 179(b).
`SEC. 1400S. CONDUCT OF AN ACTIVE TRADE OR BUSINESS WITHIN A NATIONAL ENTERPRISE
ZONE BY CORPORATIONS, PARTNERSHIPS, AND SOLE PROPRIETORS.
`(a) ACTIVE TRADE OR BUSINESS- For purposes of this subchapter, the conduct
of active trade or business means the conduct of a trade or business that
derives no more than 5 percent of its gross income from passive activities
(as defined by section 469(c)).
`(b) INCOME AND EXPENSES WITHIN A NATIONAL ENTERPRISE ZONE-
`(1) GROSS INCOME- Gross income from within a National Enterprise Zone shall
mean--
`(A) compensation for labor or personal services performed by a natural
person who is based in a National Enterprise Zone;
`(B) rentals or royalties from property located in a National Enterprise
Zone;
`(C) gains, profits, and income derived from the sale of inventory property
held within a National Enterprise Zone; and
`(D) income from the sale of property that is produced, created, fabricated,
manufactured, extracted, processed, cured, aged, grown, or harvested within
the zone.
`(2) EXPENSES- Expenses shall be allocated and apportioned to the income
producing activities to which they are related. Expenses which are not allocable
or apportioned to any specific income producing activities shall be allocated
on the basis of gross income such that the ratio of the expense allocated
to the National Enterprise Zone is the same as the ratio of gross income
within the National Enterprise Zone to all gross income within the United
States of the taxpayer or, in the case of a corporation that is a member
of a controlled group of corporations (within the meaning of section 1563),
the controlled group of such taxpayer.
`(c) ALTERNATIVE FORMULARY METHOD-
`(1) IN GENERAL- A corporation (or controlled group in the case of a corporation
that is a member of a controlled group), partnership, or sole proprietor
that so elects, in a form and manner prescribed by the Secretary, may determine
the share of its income, expense, and other items attributable to the conduct
of an active trade or business within a National Enterprise Zone by multiplying
its apportionment ratio by the amount of the income, expense, and other
items for purposes of determining its National Enterprise Zone Corporate
taxable income.
`(2) APPORTIONMENT RATIO- The apportionment ratio shall be the ratio of--
`(i) the remaining basis in depreciable property held in zone for the
entire taxable year;
`(ii) the inventory held in a zone at the end of the taxable year; and
`(iii) the compensation paid to zone-based employees during the taxable
year; to
`(i) the remaining basis in depreciable property held in the United
States for the entire taxable year;
`(ii) the inventory held in the United States at the end of the taxable
year; and
`(iii) the compensation paid to employees within the United States during
the taxable year.
`(3) MANDATORY USE OF ALTERNATIVE FORMULARY METHOD- If--
`(A) a taxpayer derives greater than 10 percent of its gross income from
sales to related parties (as defined in section 1313(c)); or
`(B) expenses of a taxpayer attributable to purchases from related parties
(as defined in section 1313(c)) account for greater than 10 percent of
its expenses,
then the taxpayer must use the alternative formulary method described in
paragraph (1).
`SEC. 1400T. DEFINITIONS AND SPECIAL RULES.
`(a) BASED IN A NATIONAL ENTERPRISE ZONE- A person is based in a National
Enterprise Zone if that person works out of an office, factory, store, or
other facility located in a National Enterprise Zone not less than 80 percent
of the hours worked by such person in a calendar year. In the case of a person
that works for an employer for less than the full calendar year or was engaged
in the conduct of an active trade or business within a National Enterprise
Zone for less than the full calendar year, then a person shall be deemed based
in a National Enterprise Zone if that person worked out of an office, factory,
store, or other facility located in a National Enterprise Zone not less than
80 percent of the hours worked by such person while employed by such employer
or engaged in the conduct of an active trade or business within a National
Enterprise Zone.
`(1) INVENTORY PROPERTY- For purposes of sections 1400P and 1400R, inventory
property shall mean property described in section 1221(a)(1) and any expenditures
capitalized pursuant to section 263A.
`(2) NO DOUBLE COUNTING- The deductions afforded by section 1400P(d)(3)
and 1400R(b)(1) are in lieu of the deduction provided upon the sale of inventory
property.
`(c) NOMINATOR- Nominator means the governor of a State or Territory or the
Mayor of the District of Columbia who nominated a zone by application to be
a National Enterprise Zone.
`(d) RESIDENCY- For purposes of this subchapter, an individual is a resident
in a National Enterprise Zone for an entire taxable year if--
`(1) such individual's principal residence (within the meaning of section
121) is located within the National Enterprise Zone; and
`(2) such individual was present (within the meaning of section 7701(b)(3))
in the National Enterprise Zone no fewer than 245 days during the taxable
year.'.
(b) CONFORMING AMENDMENTS-
(1) Section 179 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 is amended by inserting
at the end the following new subsection:
`(e) NO LIMITATION ON AMOUNT IN NATIONAL ENTERPRISE ZONES-
`(1) IN GENERAL- The limitations under subsection (b) shall not apply with
respect to property placed in service in a National Enterprise Zone.
`(2) PROPERTY REMOVED FROM NATIONAL ENTERPRISE ZONES- Property to which
this subsection applies which is removed from service within a National
Enterprise Zone but not disposed of by the taxpayer shall be treated as
if it had been, as of the date of the removal, disposed of by the taxpayer
and repurchased by the taxpayer at a price equal to what its remaining basis
would have been if the election under this section had not been exercised
with respect to the property.'.
(2) Subsection (d) of section 243 of such Code is amended by adding at the
end the following new paragraph:
`(5) A domestic corporation which is subject to taxation under this chapter
shall include any corporation organized under the laws of the Commonwealth
of Puerto Rico for any taxable year for which such corporation has made
an election under section 1400Q.'.
(c) CLERICAL AMENDMENT- The table of subchapters for chapter 1 of such Code
is amended by inserting after the item relating to subchapter Y the following
new item:
`Subchapter Z--National Enterprise Zones.'.
(d) EFFECTIVE DATE- The amendments made by this section shall apply to taxable
years beginning after January 1, 2006.
END